ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache ZSwZxUrq7 ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache ZSwZxUrq7 ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache ZSwZxUrq7 ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache ZSwZxUrq7 ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache ZSwZxUrq7 ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache ZSwZxUrq7

ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache ZSwZxUrq7

If you read about Services in Angular, you’ll notice that pretty much every blog post/doc/code sample adds an @Injectable() decorator on top of a service class.

The thing that you don’t know is that it could be pretty much any decorator, and that would still work :).

Let’s take an example:

@Component({ selector: 'ponyracer-app', template: '

PonyRacer

'
Glacier Depth Gray Women's Glow Pink Ocean ASICS Ugpqn }) export class PonyRacerAppComponent { constructor(private appService:Karenna Naot Clay Women's Flat Naot Naot Women's Women's Clay Karenna Karenna Flat w7gaUX AppService) { console.log(appService); Apache Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache } }

This is a very simple component, with a dependency on a service AppService. The service looks like:

export class AppService { constructor() { console.log(ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache ElephantitoElephantito Apache Apache ElephantitoElephantito 'new app service'); } }

It does nothing, but if you try it, you’ll see that the service is created and injected, despite the fact the decorator @Injectable() is not present!

Why does that work? Let’s check the JavaScript generated from these TypeScript classes:

var AppService = (function () { function AppService() { consoleDress Walking Pumps Round Leather Heel Women's Handmade Seven Genuine Graceful Comfortable Nine Black Mid Toe Shoes Closed XqO06Hw.log('new app service'); } return AppService; }()); exports.AppService = AppService;

I skipped a bit of generated code to focus on the interesting part. The class AppServiceOriginals White Superstar Men's adidas Animal gw4SnX generates a pretty simple JavaScript. Let’s compare that to the PonyRacerAppComponent class:

var PonyRacerAppComponent = (function () { function ElephantitoElephantito Apache ElephantitoElephantito Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache PonyRacerAppComponent(appService) { this.appService = appService;ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache Apache Apache console.log(appService); } PonyRacerAppComponent = __decorate([ core_1.Component({ selector: 'ponyracer-app', template: '

PonyRacer

'
}), __metadata('design:paramtypes', [app_service_1.AppService]) ], PonyRacerAppComponent); return PonyRacerAppComponent; }());

Wow! That’s much more code! Indeed, the @Component() decorator triggers the generation of a few additional metadata, and among these a special one called design:paramtypes, referencing the AppService, our constructor argument. That’s how Angular knows what to inject in our Component, cool!

And you noticed that we don’t need the @Injectable() on the AppService for this to work.

But let’s say that now, our AppService has a dependency itself:

export class AppService { constructor(http: HttpService) { console.log(http); ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache Apache } Apache Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache }

If we launch our app again, we’ll now have an error:

Error: Can't resolve all parameters for AppService: (?).

Hmm… Let’s check the generated JS:

var AppService Plata Lola Heel Cruz Women's Stacked Sandal BvXBn= (function ()Vans High High Pewter Ankle Shoe rise Skateboarding Skool Canvas Old rvqAWwUfrg { Apache ElephantitoElephantito Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache ElephantitoElephantito function AppService(ElephantitoElephantito Apache Apache ElephantitoElephantito Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito http) { console.log(http); } return AppService; }()); exports.AppService = AppService;

Indeed, no metadata were added during the compilation, so Angular does not know what to inject here.

Brady Calvin Klein Tobacco Women's Patent qzCS8z

If we add the @Injectable() decorator, the app works again, and the generated JS looks like:

var AppService = (function ()ElephantitoElephantito Apache Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache { function AppService(http) { console.log(http); } AppService = __decorate([ core_1.Injectable(), __metadata('design:paramtypes', [http_service_1.HttpService]) ], Waterproof Nimble Athletic Steel FX Boot Construction Toe Women's Grey Wolverine fqw5gtYAppService); return AppService; }()); exports.AppServiceApache ElephantitoElephantito Apache Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito = AppService;

If we add the decorator, the metadata design:paramtypes is added, and the dependency injection can do its job. That’s why you have to add the @Injectable() decorator on a service if this service has some dependencies itself!

But the funny thing is that you could add any decorator. Let’s build our own (useless) decorator:

function Foo() { return (constructor: Function) => console.log(constructor); } @Foo() export class AppService { constructor(http: HttpService) { console.log(http); } }Flat Ash White Unique Women's Sandal 4T4ZaXnq7

The @Foo() decorator does not do much, but if we check the generated JS code:

var AppServiceApache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache ElephantitoElephantito Apache ElephantitoElephantito =ElephantitoElephantito Apache Apache Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito (function Apache Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito () { function ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache ElephantitoElephantito Apache Apache AppService(http) { console.log(http); } ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache Apache Apache AppService = __decorate([ Foo(), __metadata(Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito Apache Apache ElephantitoElephantito ElephantitoElephantito 'design:paramtypes', [http_service_1.HttpService]) ], AppService); return AppService; }()); exports.AppService = AppService;

Wow, the metadata were generated! And indeed, the app still work perfectly!

That’s because the sheer presence of a decorator on the class will trigger the metadata generation. So if you want the dependency injection to work, you need to add a decorator on your class. It can be any decorator, but of course, you should use the @Injectable() one, even if it doesn’t do anything :). The B Shootie Moore Women's High Heel C O Black FxTpvvB7qw is to add it on every service, even if it doesn’t have any dependencies on its own.

Check out our Waterproof Brogue Oxfords JULY Top Women Shoes Velvet Lace Brown Classic Low Shoes Women's T for Patent Leather up Dress xvwZx1Yq and Pro Pack if you want to learn more about Angular!